Classical CD Reviews

New classical music releases reviewed in detail by Gavin Dixon

Wednesday, 20 December 2017

WAGNER Die Walküre Thielemann



WAGNER Die Walküre
Christian Thielemann, cond
Peter Seiffert Siegmund
Georg Zeppenfeld Hunding
Vitalij Kowaljow Wotan
Anja Harteros Sieglinde
Anja Kampe Brünnhilde
Christa Mayer Fricka
Staatskapelle Dresden
C MAJOR 742904 (Blu-ray: 235:00) Live: Salzburg: 4/5–17/2017



This Walküre was staged at Salzburg in 2017, but harks back to an earlier era. That year marked the 50th anniversary of the Salzburg Easter Festival, and to commemorate the occasion, the first production in the event’s history was re-created. So what we have is the Karajan/Schneider-Siemssen with some slight adjustments for modern times by director Vera Nemirova. The sets are essentially those of 1967, with the glass screen backstage effects now achieved though computer projections. The costumes have changed though (the new designs by Jens Kilian), with the strictly abstract, neo-Bayreuth style of the original replaced by what seems to be 60s mufti. So, for example, Vitalij Kowaljow wears a huge fur coat as Wotan, but beneath is a 1960s business suit. Given the highly acrimonious state of aesthetic politics when it comes to opera staging these days, especially in Wagner, the whole project seems dubiously regressive, and if the 60s additions are designed to bridge the gap, they are a token gesture at best.
For act I, Hunding’s house is formed by the roots of the ash tree, an impressive and imposing piece of stagecraft dominating the Festspielhaus stage. Acts II and III have a more abstract setting, a ring set on the stage and broken at the back with one arm raised—so that’s the mountain peak on which Brünnhilde (Anja Kampe) is exiled at the end. The glass paintings-turned-computer projection backdrops consist of a lot of smoke effects in the first act, and later on a huge eye looking down on proceedings. Beyond that, the physical props are minimal. The valkyries have impressive feather-crested helmets, but ride hobby horses.  Fricka (Christa Mayer) is flanked by two rams—men with ram skull helmets—but her chariot is a beige easy chair that they carry on for her. Once that has gone, there is very little on the stage for the remainder of the opera. The Magic Fire follows the inner rim of the ring on the stage, which isn’t very impressive, but is supplemented by a torchlit procession of fallen soldiers over the final bars.
The musical side is more impressive, and the festival has assembled a world-class cast, most of whom are on top form throughout. The two leading ladies, both Anjas, give the finest performances, Anja Harteros as Sieglinde and Anja Kampe as Brünnhilde. Harteros has a rich, sweet tone and excellent vocal support, which Thielemann exploits for his steady tempos and long lines. Kampe has a brighter sound, which is perfectly even, right up to the top. The musical highlight here is act III, scene 1, for the Brünnhilde/Sieglinde interactions, the two voices equally accomplished and both perfectly cast.
Peter Sieffert is on his way down—but from what heights! He was 63 when this was filmed, and he still has all the vocal power of his younger years. But the tone is more husky and lacks bloom. There is also a wobble in the most taxing passages, like the act I finale. Even so, this is still an impressive performance, and one that few of his younger rivals could match. Georg Zeppenfeld is a reliable Wagner bass, but he seems miscast as Hunding. Maybe I’ve just seen him too often as Pogner, Marke, and Heinrich, but it is difficult to take him seriously as a bad guy. Nemirov has him groping Sieglinde to demonstrate his menace, but the aggression in his voice is more effective. Christa Mayer has an appropriately mature sound for Fricka, and plenty of character in her voice. She is a good balance to Kowaljow’s Wotan, whose voice is sufficient but not huge. All the words are there, and all the emotions, but he can’t compete with Kampe, who completely dominates the final scene.
Thielemann delivers a typically excellent account of the score. His tempos are generally slow but always fluid, and skillfully communicated to the singers. One big difference from the Karajan days of the Salzburg Easter Festival is that the Berlin Philharmonic has decamped, now spending its Easters at Baden Baden. But given the beautifully idiomatic performance here from the Staatskapelle Dresden, few are likely to complain. The woodwind solos are particularly elegant, though every section of the orchestra excels.
Given the huge stage, it is understandable that the camerawork is mostly close-ups, but, apart from a few arty slow zooms, the cameras are usually static, with unobtrusive editing. The surround sound on the Blu-ray is good, giving a sense of space and depth to both the stage and the pit. Subtitles are provided in German, English, French, Spanish, Italian, Korean, and Japanese, suggesting that C Major are reaching out to a wide audience with this release. It should find a receptive audience in all those regions, though more for its musical virtues than its recycled visual conception.

This review appears in Fanfare magazine issue 41:4

Tuesday, 19 December 2017

TANEYEV String Quartets 2 and 6 California String Quartet



Sergei Taneyev: String Quartets Nos. 2 and 6
California String Quartet
CENTAUR 358


This recording of Taneyev’s Quartets Nos. 2 and 6 comes hard on the heels of a complete cycle from the Carpe Diem String Quartet on Naxos. In fact, the California String Quartet made their recordings in 2014–15, immediately before the release of the Carpe Diem’s Sixth, which perhaps accounts for the new one being delayed until now. But it was worth the wait, as these are excellent performances, and the California String Quartet clearly has something new to say.
Prior to the Carpe Diem cycle, the only commercial recording of these works was a complete cycle by the Taneyev Quartet, recorded in Leningrad in the late 70s, and reissued on the Northern Flowers label in 2005. The Taneyevs and the Carpe Diem take contrasting approaches to the music: the former broad, expansive, and Romantic, the latter brisker and more focused. The California String Quartet sits somewhere in between, leaning closer to the Carpe Diems, but generally adopting broader tempos and a warmer tone.
All the different versions are recorded in good sound—some noise reduction on the Taneyev Quartet cycle gives an artificial rounded quality to the sound, but it’s good for its age and provenance. Taneyev’s music is often highly contrapuntal, so detail is required, especially from the viola and cello. Although the lower instruments are presented in excellent detail on the Carpe Diem release, this new version offers even greater clarity, with a wide stereo separation—viola and cello on the right—and the viola (Zach Dellinger) particularly prominent when required.
Taneyev also makes heavy demands on the violins, who are often required to play with a weighty, broad tone, even in the highest registers. The Taneyev Quartet manage this better than either of the more recent competitors, but the sweetness of tone and blend of ensemble that the California Quartet brings to the tuttis is compelling too, a more approachable and involving sound, if not quite as dramatic. The California Quartet also takes a stricter approach to phrasing than the Taneyevs, with phrase endings sometimes sounding clipped, at least by comparison. The exception is the Adagio third movement of the Second Quartet, which really benefits in the California reading from their combination of long, flowing phrases, and rich, well-sustained sonorities. The California Quartet also gives the most convincing reading of the Scherzo second movement. It’s the slowest of the three accounts, but the clean, precise textures and the incisive accents make it the most dynamic-sounding and vibrant.
The Sixth Quartet is Taneyev’s last work in the form (Nos. 7–9 predate No. 1 and were published after his death), and after the Second is the most accomplished of the cycle. Although of a similar length, it’s not as expansive or symphonic as the Second, so the California Quartet’s dynamic approach proves ideal. My generalization about tempos doesn’t hold for every movement here: Of the three accounts, the California Quartet gives the slowest accounts of the first, third, and fourth movements and the fastest of the second. In comparison to the later accounts, the Taneyev Quartet’s Adagio serioso second movement is a real outlier, a minute and a half longer than either of the others, but the California Quartet demonstrates that a brisker tempo is ideal. This movement is the highlight of the quartet, with a stately pavane-like melody over a steady walking bass, much like the passacaglia movements in many of Taneyev’s other works. It is given real shape by the California Quartet, and not just through the faster tempo, but also the more disciplined phrasing and unity of ensemble.
This new account from the California String Quartet can be easily recommended as a first choice for both works. All three accounts are worth hearing though, and the Taneyev Quartet in particular brings different qualities to the music: Taneyev balances Baroque counterpoint against Romantic expression, and while the California and Carpe Diem bring out the former, the Taneyev Quartet clearly inhabit that Russian Romanticism in a way their American successors don’t. Perhaps the California Quartet are planning a full cycle of their own, which would certainly be welcome. But even if it doesn’t happen, they have done Taneyev’s fans a favor by coupling his two finest string quartets together for the first time, and in readings that consistently match, and often exceed, the competition.   

This review appears in Fanfare magazine issue 41:4

Wednesday, 13 December 2017

WAGNER Siegfried Jaap van Zweden Hong Kong PO



WAGNER Siegfried
Jaap van Zweden, cond; Simon O’Neill (Siegfried); Valentina Farcas (Forest Bird); Heidi Melton (Brünnhilde); Deborah Humble (Erda); David Cangelosi (Mime); Matthias Goerne (Wanderer); Werner Van Mechelen (Alberich); Falk Struckmann (Fafner); Hong Kong PO
NAXOS 0069 (Blu-ray audio: 241:58) Live: Hong Kong 1/6–25/2017


Jaap van Zweden’s Hong Kong Ring cycle continues apace, a flagship project for Naxos and a boost too for the Hong Kong Philharmonic’s international standing. When the project was launched, with Rheingold in 2013, it was a victim of bad timing, coinciding with a far superior version, also from concert performances, from Simon Rattle and the Bavarian Radio Symphony (BR Klassik 900133). But no cycle followed from Munich, and since then, Ring recordings have been few, at least audio versions. The Naxos cycle also has an almost unique selling point of being in high-definition surround sound—in Blu-ray audio, the preferred format of Naxos over SACD—and the results fully justify the technology. The interpretation and casting are good, although neither stands comparison with the historical best, and views on the lead singers are likely to come down to personal taste.
Everything about this performance speaks of careful preparation and investment of time. German opera house orchestras have dominated the recent Ring discography, especially on DVD, but the Hong Kong Philharmonic is clearly a different ensemble. They don’t have the burnished string tone or the warmth from the woodwinds of a Central European Ensemble, though the brightness and clarity they offer instead is a bonus, even if it leads to a slight sense of detachment from the drama. The string sound, while usually secure in ensemble, can be thin, especially with the violins in the top register, leading to a transparency in the tutti textures—impressively clear but occasionally uninvolving. Zweden, for his part, gives a measured but fluid reading. Tempos are generally mid-range to slow, though he always builds impressively to climaxes. He communicates well with the singers, offering generous supporting textures, but also reigning in any rubato excesses. All round, a real ensemble performance then, meticulously prepared and well presented.
The cast is a curious mix of Wagner veterans, relatively new names, and, in the case of Matthias Goerne’s Wanderer, a Lieder singer branching out into pastures new.  In fact, Goerne has a reasonable track record with Wagner, having sung Wolfram, Amfortas, and Kurnewal onstage, but he still sounds like a Leider recitalist seeking for the vocal weight and dramatic presence required to bring the role off. His sound is more volume than heft, big on character but lacking in gravitas, and with a hazy quality that you either love or hate. His diction is excellent though, and he fits well into the ensemble. Simon O’Neill is a similar case as Siegfried. For all his undeniable musical qualities, the most apparent trait—or flaw, depending on your perspective—is his plumy English accent (though he is actually a New Zealander). He is a very lyrical Siegfried, too lyrical perhaps, as he often sounds Italianate in his rounded, florid phrasing. But he has plenty of Wagner on disc already, so buyers will know where they stand.
The rest of the cast is less controversial and generally very fine. David Cangelosi is an articulate Mime, mildly sinister and certainly not caricatured. Werner Van Mechelen is a little hollow-sounding as Alberich, but hardly to a fault. Falk Struckmann probably counts as luxury casting here as Fafner. He is not as profundo as some, but he’s still ominous. Deborah Humble has a very young-sounding voice for Erde, and struggles with some of the lower notes. She has a heavy vibrato too, that sometimes sounds labored. Brünnhilde isn’t a huge role in this opera, but Heidi Melton makes the most of it. Her tone is a little thin at the top, but all the notes are there, and she and Simon O’Neill bring the third act to a suitable passionate conclusion.
The surround sound is involving, though it does the orchestra more favors than the cast. By accident or design, the anvil in the Prelude appears at the back left of the soundstage, just as the libretto specifies. There are some thunder effects, which seem pasted on, though they probably worked better live. The timpani dominates the center channel and sounds more closely miked than most of the orchestra. The singers occasionally seem distant: Siegfried, for example, seems to begin offstage, coming towards the microphone for his first entry, and, as the Forest Bird, Valentina Farcas, seems to be positioned behind the orchestra or in some other remote spot stage left. She sings well, but the recording doesn’t do her justice. The orchestra, however, is afforded a spacious setting, all the more welcome given that most DVDs of staged Wagner operas don’t explore their surround sound capabilities for the back of the pit. The Hong Kong Cultural Centre Concert Hall seems to have a fairly dry acoustic, so there isn’t much going on in the rear speakers.
An impressive, if not exceptional, Siegfried then, from Jaap van Zweden and his Hong Kong forces.  Unless you’re a diehard Goerne fan, you’re unlikely to seek it out for the cast, but Zweden’s detailed reading, along with the quality of the orchestral playing and the audio elevate the project, and auger well for the Götterdämmerung to come.